Shows Like History's Greatest Mysteries

If you loved History's Greatest Mysteries, here is what to watch next - thriller and mystery shows ranked by popularity and community rating on WatchSocial. Each pick shows why it is a match, so you can find your next binge fast.

Get personalized recommendations

Shows like History's Greatest Mysteries

• Fatal Attraction - Thriller · 2013 · rated 10.0/10
• Kudlow - Thriller · 2021
• The Secret of Skinwalker Ranch - Thriller, Mystery · 2020
• Snapped: Killer Couples - Thriller · 2013
• Secrets Declassified with David Duchovny - Thriller, Mystery, History · 2025
• Law & Order: Special Victims Unit - Mystery · 1999 · rated 10.0/10
• Supernatural - Mystery · 2005 · rated 8.8/10
• FROM - Mystery · 2022 · rated 8.5/10
• The Prosecutor's Proposal - Mystery · 2026
• Criminal Minds - Mystery · 2005 · rated 10.0/10
• CSI: Crime Scene Investigation - Mystery · 2000
• Midsomer Murders - Mystery · 1997
• The Mentalist - Mystery · 2008
• Stranger Things - Mystery · 2016 · rated 9.0/10
• Dexter - Mystery · 2006 · rated 9.0/10
• The Blacklist - Mystery · 2013 · rated 10.0/10
• Detective Conan - Mystery · 1996
• Desperate Housewives - Mystery · 2004 · rated 7.0/10
• CSI: Miami - Mystery · 2002
• Perry Mason - Mystery · 1957
• Pritam and Pedro - Mystery · 2026
• Lost - Mystery · 2004 · rated 6.0/10
• Elementary - Mystery · 2012 · rated 4.0/10
• NCIS: Los Angeles - Mystery · 2009

More

• History's Greatest Mysteries - cast, episodes and ratings
• Discover TV shows and movies
• TV and movie lists
• Famous birthdays
• Compare TV trackers
• Renewed or cancelled